RPG Developer Bakin Editor Early Access Review - Revision history

Yanfly: /* Version 1.2 Score Change */

2023-03-18T02:20:52Z

‎Version 1.2 Score Change

2023-03-17T18:37:47Z

‎Version 1.2 Score Change

2023-03-17T18:35:49Z

‎Version 1.2 Score Change

2023-03-17T18:35:31Z

‎Overall Score Rating

2023-03-17T18:34:42Z

‎Version 1.1 Update

2023-03-17T18:34:30Z

‎Score Rating for Database

2023-03-17T18:30:51Z

‎version 1.2 Score Change

2023-03-17T18:28:00Z

‎version 1.2 Score Change

2023-03-17T18:25:00Z

‎Version 1.2 Update

2023-03-17T18:24:18Z

‎Overall Score Rating

@@ Line 1,710: / Line 1,710: @@
 To me, this is NOT a bad score at all.
 This already puts it in roughly the same league as RPG Maker VXA/MV/MZ.
-And even if you consider it to be, what this update tells me is that there is promise for Bakin.
+And even if you consider it to be a bad score, what this update tells me is that there is promise for Bakin.
 The fact that Bakin addressed the plugin/scripting as a major aspect hindering its growth so early on (as a version 1.2 update of all things) tells me that the developers take their product very seriously.

@@ Line 1,715: / Line 1,715: @@
 The database update for version 1.1 allows for numeric entries for certain database settings and that's already a step in the right direction.
 But I never expected the 1.2 change to suddenly have this.
 Kudos!

@@ Line 1,707: / Line 1,707: @@
 <youtube>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGPyxn2hCh8</youtube>
-With the [https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/1036640/view/3671034592386443689?l=english version 1.2 update], Bakin has broken out of a 5.9 to a 7.1 for me!
+With the [https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/1036640/view/3671034592386443689?l=english version 1.2 update], Bakin has broken out of a 5.9 to a 7.45 for me!
 To me, this is NOT a bad score at all.
 This already puts it in roughly the same league as RPG Maker VXA/MV/MZ.

@@ Line 1,658: / Line 1,658: @@
 * 8/10 x 5 - '''Map Editor'''
 * 6/10 x 3 - '''Resource Manager'''
-* 3/10 x 5 - '''Database'''
+* <s>3/10 x 5 - '''Database'''</s>
 * 10/10 x 1 - '''Game Definition'''
 * 8/10 x 5 - '''UI Layout Tool'''
@@ Line 1,666: / Line 1,667: @@
 * 8/10 x 5 - '''Event Editor'''
 * <s>0/10 x 5 - '''Expanded Features (Custom Code)'''</s>
-* 8/10 x 5 - '''Expanded Features (Custom Code)'''
+* 8/10 x 5 - '''Expanded Features (Custom Code)''' (Version 1.2)
 <s>196 / 330 = 5.9/10</s>
-/ 330 = 7.1/10
+/ 330 = 7.45/10
-'''Overall Score:''' 7.1/10
+'''Overall Score:''' 7.45/10
@@ Line 1,701: / Line 1,702: @@
 Get it?</s>
 === Version 1.2 Score Change ===

@@ Line 1,154: / Line 1,154: @@
 This makes a lot more sense for things like the aforementioned state effects.
-It's not a big improvement, but it's enough to shift it from a 3 to a 5 for me.
+It's not a big improvement, but it's important enough to shift it from a 3 to a 5 for me.
 == Game Definition ==

@@ Line 1,140: / Line 1,140: @@
 While "Cast" events are extremely useful, it doesn't really offset the setbacks the rest of the database has.
-'''Score:''' 3/10
+<s>'''Score:''' 3/10</s>
 <hr>
 == Game Definition ==

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:28, 17 March 2023
Line 1,694:		Line 1,694:
	=== version 1.2 Score Change ===		=== version 1.2 Score Change ===

		+	<youtube>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uGPyxn2hCh8</youtube>
		+
		+	With the [https://store.steampowered.com/news/app/1036640/view/3671034592386443689?l=english version 1.2 update], Bakin has broken out of a 5.9 to a 7.1 for me!
		+	To me, this is NOT a bad score at all.
		+	This already puts it in the same league as RPG Maker.
		+	And even if you consider it to be, what this update tells me is that there is promise for Bakin.
		+
		+	The fact that Bakin addressed the plugin/scripting as a major aspect hindering its growth so early on (as a version 1.2 update of all things) tells me that the developers take their product very seriously.

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:25, 17 March 2023
Line 1,601:		Line 1,601:

	While I cannot give Bakin a full score for the scripting/plugin support, I can definitely give it a high 8 for prioritizing the two aspects of what makes JRPG's unique.		While I cannot give Bakin a full score for the scripting/plugin support, I can definitely give it a high 8 for prioritizing the two aspects of what makes JRPG's unique.
		+	And what really shocks me is that there's even a whole [https://rpgbakin.com/pukiwiki_en/ wiki] dedicated to all of this.
		+	Might be biased here, but I think the presence of a wiki changes absolutely everything!

	'''Score:''' 8/10		'''Score:''' 8/10

@@ Line 1,651: / Line 1,651: @@
 * 7/10 x 1 - '''Sprite Tool'''
 * 8/10 x 5 - '''Event Editor'''
-* 0/10 x 5 - '''Expanded Features (Custom Code)'''
+* <s>0/10 x 5 - '''Expanded Features (Custom Code)'''</s>
-/ 330 = 5.9/10
+<s>196 / 330 = 5.9/10</s>
 Currently as it is, Bakin is not fit for professional game development.
 For hobbyist games, it's a very fine tool.
 But just not for professional game development.
@@ Line 1,683: / Line 1,686: @@
 ......
-Get it?
+Get it?</s>
 <hr>
 |}